Rev. Dr. George Harvey Ball
First President, 1890-1904
Rev. John Chester Ball
Second President, 1904-1906
Rev. Dr. Zephaniah A. Space
Third President, 1907-1909
Rev. Arthur Braden
Fourth President, 1909-1910
Rev. Joseph A. Serena
Fifth President, 1910-1915
Dr. Arthur H. Norton
Sixth President, 1919-1935
Dr. J. Hillis Miller
Seventh President, 1935-1941
Dr. Henry E. Allen
Eighth President, 1941-1946
Dr. Katherine Gillette Blyley
Ninth President, 1947-1958
Dr. William Spencer Litterick
Tenth President, 1959-1965
Dr. Wilbour Eddy Saunders
Eleventh President (Interim), 1965-1966
Dr. G. Wayne Glick
Twelfth President, 1966-1974
Dr. William L. Boyle, Jr.
Thirteenth President, 1975-1978
Dr. Eric J. Stettner
Fourteenth President (Interim), 1978
Dr. Elizabeth Woods Shaw
Fifteenth President, 1978-1983
Dr. Arthur F. Kirk, Jr.
Sixteenth President, 1983-1996
Frank P. Strong, Jr.
Seventeenth President (Interim), 1997
Dr. Joseph G. Burke
Eighteenth President, 1997–2011
Dr. Jorge L. Díaz-Herrera
Nineteenth President, 2011-2018
Amy Storey
Twentieth President, 2018-present